Want to make sure you have treats that ALL kids can enjoy on Halloween? Make sure you keep a few non-candy goodies on hand! If you need inspiration for a few inexpensive ideas, I’ve got you covered. Read on for 20 candy-free ideas that are all treats and no tricks!

Want your house to be the hit of Halloween for ALL kids, including those who can't have sweets? I've rounded up 20 awesome candy-free Halloween treats that will wow your trick or treaters! These are perfect for Teal Pumpkin Project houses! 

First, don’t get me wrong, I adore candy! If your kids can tolerate it, then by all means, let them indulge on Halloween. After all, it only comes around once a year. However, Halloween is supposed to be fun for all kids, not just those who can eat sacks full of candy without going into anaphylactic shock, a diabetic coma or worse.

The hard part, of course, is finding candy alternatives that are just as fun as chocolate AND won’t cost you the equivalent of a king-sized bar for every child. Below are 25 ideas that are easy on the budget yet still make the trek to your front door totally worth the trip.

FYI, this post contains affiliate links, which means if you buy anything through them, I get a tiny commission at no extra charge to you. Thanks!


20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats

*This post does contain affiliate links. That means if you click on the links and make a purchase, I get a tiny commission.

1. Punching Balloons!

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

Punch balloons like this Creepy Halloween Ghoulish set are always a hit in my house! Even teens love them (and yes, you should absolutely give out treats to teens, because they deserve to have fun just as much as tiny tots).

Amscan Creepy Halloween Ghoulish Punch Balloon (16 Piece), Multicolor, 12" x 7 1/2"
  • ASSORTED COLORS: Choose from a vibrant and exciting assortment of 16 Spooky Fun Halloween Latex Punch Balloons, perfect for adding a splash of color to any thrilling celebration or kids' party!
  • PREMIUM LATEX MATERIAL: Made from high-quality, eco-friendly latex, our Spooky Fun Halloween Punch Balloons are durable enough to withstand the most enthusiastic revelers, ensuring endless bouncing entertainment for everyone.
  • IDEAL FOR CELEBRATIONS & PARTIES: Elevate any spooky celebration or children's party with our Spooky Fun Halloween Punch Balloons, perfect for enhancing the atmosphere and creating lasting memories with family and friends.
  • ECO-FRIENDLY & DURABLE: Make a responsible choice for the environment with our Spooky Fun Halloween Latex Punch Balloons, designed to be reusable and sturdy, ideal for making your celebrations more enjoyable and sustainable.
  • BOOST YOUR HALLOWEEN FESTIVITIES: Don't miss out on the ultimate Halloween accessory, order your Spooky Fun Halloween Latex Punch Balloons today and experience the difference that these delightful decorations can make at your next gathering!

2. These glowing eye balls!

bouncing eyeballs

My son never gets tired of creepy bouncy balls, especially if they glow in the dark! Plus, when it inevitably rolls under the couch, at least you’ll be able to find it!

GIFTEXPRESS 24ct, 32MM Glow in The Dark Eyeball/Glow in The Dark Bouncy Ball/Halloween Supplies/Halloween Treats/Halloween Toys/Toy Eyeball (24 pc Eyeball)
  • Pack of 24, 1.25" diameter Glow in the Dark Eyeball
  • Glow in the dark Halloween eyeballs
  • Perfect Halloween toys and treats
  • Not Just for Halloween! Kids will enjoy year round fun playing with these glow in the bouncy balls!
  • Tips for glow in the dark toy: you can put them under the sun or hold them up to a strong light, they will adsorb and light and glow in the dark for many hours
  • High Quality: Made of high quality rubber with consistent roundness, density and bounciness

3. Crazy fun wind up toys

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
I don’t care how old (or how cool) you are, wind up toys never cease to amuse!

JOYIN 12 PCS Halloween Wind Up Toy Assortments for Halloween Party Favor, Halloween Toys for Kids, Goody Bag Filler,Treat Bag Stuffers
  • Wind-Up Toys Set: 12 Different Design Wind-Up Toys in one set, each with its own unique charm and action-packed fun.
  • Unique and Fun Functional Design. Start to Wind Them Up and Turn the Power on to Watch Them Hop! Invite Your Friend and Family to Enjoy the Fun Time with These Halloween Wind-Up Toys Set
  • Lots of Fun: These Scary Halloween Accessories provide a great Halloween experience for everyone. This is perfect for Halloween Decorations, Halloween Party Favor and Supplies, and Halloween Toys and Treats.
  • Interactive Play: Our wind-up toys perform various actions, including walking, shaking their heads, and rotating, bringing endless joy and laughter to kids of all ages.
  • Portable And Versatile: The compact size of our Halloween Fidget Toys makes them highly portable, allowing you to carry them with you wherever you go. Whether you're at home, in the office, or on the go, these fidget toys are perfect for quick stress relief and relaxation.

4. Rubber Duckies!

We used to have a massive collection of rubber duckies, mostly because I went through a “collect them all” phase.  This set comes with 48 adorable duckies in a ton of varieties, all for a pretty reasonable price.

5. Zombie Bendies!

Halloween rubber duckes

While I’ve never really been into zombies, there’s a reason Hollywood keeps making movies about them. The vast majority of kids do not agree with my sentiment. In other words, they’ll adore these bendies!

6. More bouncy balls!
20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
As much as I love the glowing eyeball set, you do get more for your money in this set. For about the price of a few bags of candy you get 6 dozen cute candy-free treats to give out. Plus, they’re not quite so scary for teeny tots.

7. LED Pumpkin Necklaces

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
If you don’t have a lot of trick or treaters (or have a pretty good-sized budget), these are a cute giveaway. We only have one or two every year because we live too far outside the regular trick or treat zone. Basically, coming up here isn’t worth the effort.

Windy City Novelties Original LED Light Up Halloween Pumpkin Jack O Lantern Necklace Party Favors
  • HAVE ONE HECK OF A HALLOWEEN | We know a thing or two about holiday necklaces. After all, we created the super-popular Christmas bulb necklace. Well, Halloween is our second favorite holiday! Why limit yourself to a pumpkin on the doorstep--when you wear one! Our Light Up Halloween Pumpkin Necklace features 9 grinning pumpkins. It's Halloween pumpkin jewelry at its best. Choose from three light modes: strobe, fast flash, and slow flash: Batteries included and installed.
  • HALLOWEEN DECORATIONS | You don't have to create some elaborate haunted house to give your place the spirit of Halloween. Our pumpkin necklace is also excellent for Halloween decorating. You can hang it up in different spots in and around your house. If you work in a Halloween-friendly office, hand them out as Halloween gifts.
  • HALLOWEEN PARTY FAVOR | If you plan on throwing a Halloween party, you'll want all the ghouls and goblins at your party to be happy. Be sure to add our pumpkin necklace to your Halloween party supplies. It makes a beautiful party favor.
  • BASED IN THE USA | We're proud to be a US-based, family-owned company that's been in business since 1983. Our passion is to always provide you with the best selection of unique gifts and novelties on the market.
  • INCLUDED: Light Up Halloween Pumpkin Jack O Lantern Necklace.

8. Play-Doh!

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

I love Play-Doh so much that I anxiously awaited the day my son would be old enough to play with it. Then I bought pretty much every Play-Doh set in existence. Jake is 14 now and doesn’t play with it anymore, but I broke out the big box when my niece and nephew were here recently!

This bag is pricey, but you get 80 mini tubs of Play Doh in it, so it’s worth it.

Play-Doh Halloween Trick or Treat Bag with 80 Fun Size Cans 0.80oz Each
  • 80 cans of fun size Play Doh (0.80 oz) - Endless fun and creativity
  • Assorted colors modeling compound
  • Ideal as party favor or Halloween trick or treat
  • Ages 2 and up
  • Assorted characters on bag

9. Wall Flingy Sticky Things

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

What is it about sticky wall tumblers? Jake has had like a million of them over the years. They get hairy and gross after a week, yes, but they sure are fun while they last! Fun fact about me: I was TERRIFIED of these things when I was a kid, especially the ones shaped like octopuses!

Wankko 72 Pieces Vinyl Stretchy Sticky Toy Assortment Including Wall Climber Men, Sticky Animals, Large Sticky Hands, Sticky Hammers, Stretchy Flying Frogs and Sticky Frogs
  • 72 Pieces Super Value Pack Includes: Wall Climber Men, Sticky Animals, Large Sticky Hands, Sticky Hammers, Stretchy Flying Frogs and Sticky Frogs (Style Random)
  • Each Piece is Individually Packed. Perfect for Birthday Party Favors, Carnival Prizes, Pinatas, Classroom Rewards, Holiday Goodie Bags.
  • Toy Set is Made from Non Toxic Safe Materials. This Toy Conforms to US Toy Standards.
  • Larger Size than Similar Products. More Varieties. Higher Value!
  • MONEY BACK GUARANTEE- "Contact Seller" and we will refund you or ship you a replacement if you have any question.

10. Zombie pencils 

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
Make learning fun with these creepy pencils! We probably have like 500 pencils in my house at this point and my son still loves getting them in favor bags.

Zombie Pencils (24 Pack)
  • 24 Colorful Zombie Pencils.
  • 7.5" Wooden pencils with number 2 lead.

11. Brain-Shaped Erasers

These would go great with the pencils! They’re simple and funny yet oddly cute, aren’t they? Who knew the brain would look so pretty in pink?

12. Not so creepy erasers

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
Something a little less creepy for the younger kids, this assortment comes with both pencils and adorable erasers.

Raymond Geddes Boo Buddies Number 2 Pencils With Giant Pencil Top Erasers (Pack of 36)
  • Cute Pencils & Erasers: Complete with cool erasers, these kids’ pencils make homework fun; These lead pencils and erasers for kids are perfect for everyday use at home, in the classroom, and more
  • Colorful Designs: Featuring 6 scary designs, these fun pencils for kids come with oversized erasers for pencils tops
  • Versatile Fun: These no 2 pencils and pencil toppers are perfect for a variety of occasions; These cool pencils and fun erasers make great teacher supplies for classroom, goodie bag stuffers, and more
  • Wood Pencils: This pencil set includes 36 wooden pencils filled with number 2 HB lead and 36 giant kids’ erasers
  • Geddes School Supplies: A family-owned business catering to over 3000 school districts since 1924, we specialize in novelty pens, erasers, slimes, toys, and cute school supplies

13. The whole shebang assortment

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
156 Piece Mega Halloween Toy Novelty Assortment

If you don’t want to limit kids to just one type of candy-free treat, assortments like this are a great option. I love this one because every item in it is pretty cool. If you opt for a different assortment, just look closely to make sure you’re not getting 500 tiny stickers and 5 cool toys. Kind of like how candy assortments always fill half of the bag with that one candy no one wants to eat.

14. Glow in the Dark Temporary Tats

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
Temporary tattoos are a great budget-friendly candy-free treat because you can get a ton of them super cheap. My son used to go through temporary tats like crazy. I’m surprised half of his DNA isn’t made up of wash-off ink.

26 Sheets (80+ Pcs ) Halloween Glow in the Dark Temporary Tattoo Sticker, Day of the Dead Sugar Skull Temporary, Halloween Tattoos for Kids
  • ABUNDANT QUANTITY: 26 sheets including 80+ design, and two different styles, include 8 sheets glow in the dark tattoos stickers, Halloween temporary tattoos , pumpkin tattoos, spider tattoos(size 120*75 mm/4.72*2.95 inch), 18 sheets Day of the dead sugar skull temporary tattoo Halloween tattoo stickers for Cos Play, day of the dead skeleton temporary tattoo(size 60*60 mm/2.36*2.36 inch)
  • LIGHT IN THE DARK HALLOWEEN KITS - Stick these glow in the dark tattoos, you would be the unique one on your party
  • HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL: The dead sugar skull temporary tattoo is waterproof, removable, long last for 2-5 days
  • VARIOUS OCCASIONS: These temporary tattoos for kids are perfect design for Halloween party cosplay dress up accessories, Day of The Dead, Night Party, make up dress up for kids
  • WATERPROOF & NON-TOXIC :Halloween temporary tattoos are water proof, nontoxic, safe and fun for all ages including kids & adults

15.Sugar Skull Tattoos

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
I love these for a slightly older trick or treating crowd. They’re a little more sophisticated than the cutesy monsters and pumpkins.

Sugar Skull Temporary Tattoos - Day of the Day and Halloween Accessories - 72 Pieces
  • These make great additions to your Halloween treats. As a good candy-alternative or an addition to Halloween candy these tattoos are fun and sure to please.
  • They make great favors at your Halloween party too.
  • Easy to apply and remove.
  • Bulk set of 72.
  • Size: 1 1/2". Safe and non-toxic.

16.Squishy brains!

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)
Since these only come in 3-packs, this is another giveaway that you might want to consider getting only if you have just a few visitors each year. Otherwise, you might want to look at other options that give you more to a set.

IPIDIPI TOYS Squishy Brain Fidget Splat Ball - 3 Pack - Anti Stress - Popping for Adults Children - Anxiety Reducer Sensory Play - Increases Focus Suitable for ADHD and Autism - Fun Toy for Halloween
  • CAUSE A STIR AT THE HALLOWEEN PARTY: You can create a theme party called "hit the zombies with the brains", and the kids will love it! Our brain plat ball is going to be the hit of the day and everyone will love the theme and ask you where you got the brains. Brains... brains... brains! Your little zombies will beg for these Brain-Shaped Splat balls. Pass them out to trick-or-treaters or as Halloween party favors.
  • OUR STICKY BRAIN SPLAT BALL IS SAFE, LATEX-FREE, BPA-FREE MATERIALS!! Our stick 'n' splats are made with thicker material so they last longer. We spend more on the materials to make our splats to ensure higher quality standards. We have fewer cases of breakage with normal usage than most of our competitors.
  • YOU CAN USE THEM AS SENSORY BALLS: A set of three brain balls in distinctive shapes and with different surface textures is waiting for you to get it. Great fun for throwing, catching, rolling and bouncing as the irregular shapes make them bounce and roll in unpredictable directions, challenging expectations and hand-eye coordination.
  • GET THROUGH THE DAILY STRESSES: It is lightweight, inexpensive, and it offers a soothing effect. This stress relieving brain ball is easy to squeeze and has a cute appearance which attracts attention and engages the user with its vibrant color.
  • IT'S PERFECT FOR SCHOOL PROJECTS: Order our "Squishy Brain "and use it for a science fair project or for a medical presentation for grade school kids. It's not too gory to pass off as a replica of a brain for science purposes and the price is much better than most other scientific brain models. It is a soft plastic that is lightweight enough to attach to a foam board.

17. Halloween Squishies

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

Another cute idea that’s ideal for a smaller number of ToT’ers (they’re pricey but so freaking cute), you can almost never go wrong with squishies!

JOYIN 6 Pack Halloween Themed Squishy Toys Slow Rising Stress Relief Super Soft Squeeze Kawaii Cute Halloween Friends Characters Toys for Boys Girls
  • Super Value with 6 Pieces of Halloween Themed Jumbo Size Soft squishy toy Friends Toys. Height of the Toys Measure from 3.6 Inches to 5 Inches. Including Cute Halloween Themed Characters Jack-o'-lantern, Dracula, Werewolf, Witch, Zombie and Frankenstein
  • Perfect for Stress Relief for Both Adults and Kids. Ideal as squishy toys for Kids Hand Eye Coordination, Develop Observing Ability, Cognitive Ability, Spatial Intelligence and Interpersonal Intelligence. Also Great to Boost Hand Blood Circulation.
  • So Much Fun! Your Kids Will Not Stop Squeezing These Super Soft Cute Animal Toys. Great Party Favor for Halloween and Birthday.
  • Super Quality & CHILD SAFE. These Kawaii squishy toy Animal Toys are Made with High Quality Nontoxic Silicone. They are Designed to Withstand a Large Amount of Squeezing, Pinching, Fidgeting & Stretching.
  • Stress Relief And Fun: Our Halloween squishy toys provide a therapeutic and fun way to relieve stress and anxiety. Squeeze and squish them to help relax and focus, whether it's during Halloween festivities or any time of the year.

18. Scratch and Smell Stickers

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

I haven’t seen scratch and sniff stickers in ages! I used to love collecting them when I was little.

TREND enterprises, Inc. Halloween/Licorice Stinky Stickers, 60 ct.
  • Holiday-themed stickers are seasonal favorites - and smell as good as they look!
  • Scratch 'em and sniff 'em for a burst of fragrance! Scent lasts for years of happy memories.
  • Nontoxic, acid-free, and safe to use on photos and in scrapbook albums. Scents contain no nut oils.
  • 3 designs; 4 sheets. 60 stickers total per pack. Each sticker 1" diameter.



19. Bugs!

20 Really Cool Candy-Free Halloween Treats Kids Actually WANT to Get (Perfect for Teal Pumpkin Houses)

Little pranksters will love getting realistic bugs to freak out their parents and siblings with. Trust me, I know this for a fact. I’ve been pranked with gross plastic bugs more times than I care to admit!

20. Gift Certificates

I’m not saying you should give every kid that comes to your door a $50 Amazon gift card, but you can usually buy or print packs of certificates for things like RedBox DVD rentals. french fries, and so on pretty cheap. I know both McDonald’s and Wendy’s has packs of coupons for like $1. Just watch the food certificates if the whole point of giving non-candy treats is to avoid food allergies.

These are all fun candy-free treats that kids of all ages will love. If you are the parent of a child with allergies, I’d love for you to weigh in on your favorites, and any tips that you have for making Halloween fun without the candy.

One last thing. If you are going to hand out non-candy treats, consider adding your address to the Teal Pumpkin Project Trick or Treat map so local parents can add your house to their safe route. You can also print out a Teal Pumpkin to hang in your window.


What types of fun candy-free treats do you like to give out? Share below! 





Last update on 2024-05-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API